Introduction
Here is the uncomfortable truth for beauty brands: Gen Z does not care how big your influencer is. They care whether they believe them. The brands winning this generation, Rare Beauty, e.l.f., Glossier, did not buy the most reach. They earned the most trust. And they did it with armies of small creators rather than a handful of famous faces.
This breaks down exactly how, with the real numbers and the named brands, then turns it into a playbook you can copy. Front-loaded tactical value, no fluff.
The Creator Outreach Toolkit
12 email templates that get replies, a 50-point creator vetting checklist, rate negotiation scripts and a campaign tracker. Built from 4 years of running creator campaigns.
No spam. Unsubscribe in one click. We email when we have something useful for you, never more than weekly.
What Gen Z actually wants
Start with the single most important statistic in beauty marketing right now: around 92% of Gen Z say authenticity is the most important value to them. That one number explains almost everything about how the winning brands behave.
This is the generation that invented de-influencing, creators telling their followers what not to buy. They grew up online, so they detect a forced ad instantly and punish it. They are also less brand-loyal than any generation before, happy to switch for a better deal or a more honest recommendation. The implication is blunt: a glossy, inauthentic campaign does not just underperform with Gen Z, it erodes trust. Authenticity is not a nice-to-have here. It is the entire game.
How the top brands compare
Five brands that win with Gen Z, each with a distinct strategy behind it. Notice how different the approaches are, yet how they all centre on trust.
| Brand | Lead platform | Influencer approach | Signature move |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rare Beauty | Instagram + TikTok | Micro-influencer first | No-obligation wellness retreats |
| e.l.f. Beauty | TikTok | Micro-influencer first | Community-built hero products |
| Glossier | TikTok | Top creators for launches | 3x more posts on TikTok than IG |
| The Ordinary | Macro-influencer led | Science-led ingredient trust | |
| Fenty Beauty | Instagram + TikTok | Founder-powered, community | Rihanna's organic engagement |
Sources: Lefty, Aspire, Marketing Dive, Sky Society. Approaches based on reported brand strategy analyses.
Three brands, three playbooks
The headline brands do not copy each other. Each found a different route to the same destination, Gen Z trust.
Rare Beauty
Founded by Selena Gomez, though its success is not built on her fame. Consumers buy into the mission, breaking beauty norms and destigmatising mental illness through the Rare Impact Fund, with that purpose running through its influencer strategy. Rather than extravagant parties, Rare Beauty invites small groups of creators to wellness retreats with no obligation to post. The result: it far outranks rivals on influencer coverage volume, growing 110% year over year, with over half its posts from micro-influencers.
e.l.f. Beauty
e.l.f. earned its Gen Z crown by tweaking its social strategy to live natively on TikTok and by entrenching a dedicated audience through micro-influencers early. Affordable hero products like the Power Grip Primer and Halo Glow Liquid Filter became organic sensations, generating some of the highest positive comment volume among young consumers. It proves accessible price plus authentic community beats prestige positioning with this audience.
Glossier
The original community-first brand, born from Emily Weiss's Into The Gloss blog and its honest conversations with real people. Glossier's "skin first, makeup second" ethos sells a vibe, not just product, while concentrating its strategy on TikTok, posting roughly three times more there than on Instagram. It rarely collaborates, yet when it does it picks perfectly, like Gen Z icon Olivia Rodrigo. Its experiential stores deepen the community offline too.
The Gen Z beauty playbook
Strip the case studies down and the same moves repeat. Here is the transferable playbook, in order of impact.
- Lead with micro-influencers. Many small, credible voices build more trust than a few big ones. Rare Beauty and e.l.f. both built their followings this way.
- Go TikTok-first for discovery. It is where Gen Z finds beauty, so weight your posting there, then use YouTube for the deep tutorials and reviews that cement trust.
- Give creators freedom, not scripts. Rare Beauty's no-obligation retreats produce more authentic coverage than any mandated post. Control is the enemy of credibility here.
- Embed purpose in the product. Values resonate only when they are real, like Rare Beauty's mental-health mission, not bolted on for a campaign.
- Make content formats they trust. Reviews, tutorials and get-ready-with-me content convert because they teach and feel honest.
- Pick collabs sparingly and perfectly. One Olivia Rodrigo beats ten mismatched creators. Fit matters more than frequency.
Treating influencer marketing as paid reach. The moment a partnership feels bought rather than believed, this audience tunes out or, worse, de-influences your product publicly. Every tactic above exists to keep the content feeling genuine, because with Gen Z, perceived authenticity is the conversion lever.
How to use this with Flinque
Every winning strategy here runs on the same engine: a high volume of credible micro and mid-tier creators whose audiences genuinely match the brand. Finding and vetting those creators at scale is the hard part. It is exactly what a discovery platform is for.
With Flinque you can search 10M+ verified creators by niche, filter for the micro and mid-tier beauty creators that Gen Z trusts, run a fake follower check, then benchmark engagement so you build a roster that is authentic rather than just large. Rare Beauty and e.l.f. won by finding the right small voices first. Flinque helps you do the same.
Win Gen Z the way the best beauty brands do, with the right creators.
Use Flinque to find micro and mid-tier creators by niche and audience, run a fake follower check and benchmark engagement before you build a campaign. Start free with no credit card.